Free Consultation  |   Book a Speaker  |   Log In

Buffini & Company Blog

The three conversations that change everything

By Sherri Starr McCusker, Business Coach

One of the greatest privileges of being a Buffini Coach is having a front-row seat to the breakthroughs that completely change the trajectory of an agent’s business.

What’s fascinating is that those breakthroughs rarely come from a shiny new marketing strategy, the latest social media trend, or even the perfect listing presentation (yes, even the really pretty ones).

Instead, they come as a result of having the right kind of conversation.

What conversation isn’t happening that needs to?

Every week, I hear questions like:

  • “Why aren’t my clients giving me referrals?”
  • “Why are my buyers unmotivated to take action?”
  • “How can I help my sellers be more realistic about the market?”
  • “How do I ensure a potential client chooses me over the other agents they’re interviewing?”

When Carla Harris, a top Wall Street executive and leadership expert, blessed our stages in 2025 at both the Peak Experience® and Leadership Conference™, she talked about the importance of having what she calls “adult conversations.” That phrase has stuck with me.

After thousands of coaching conversations, I’ve come to believe she’s right.

Here are the three conversations I believe every real estate professional needs to master.

1. The conversation that creates understanding

When something isn’t moving forward, our instinct is often to explain more, educate more, or convince harder.

Try curiosity instead. Ask more questions and listen intently. Seek to understand what’s underneath the objection instead of trying to overcome it.

A seller who won’t consider reducing their price may not be resisting the market but rather grieving what they thought their home was worth.

A buyer who won’t make a decision may not be indecisive, but may simply be afraid of making the wrong one.

The next time you’re tempted to ask, “How do I get them to…” try asking yourself, “What do I still need to understand?”

2. The conversation you’ve been avoiding

Every agent has that one conversation they tend to avoid. It could be about a price reduction. It may be hesitancy to ask for referrals or to check in on past clients. Or maybe it’s about setting healthy boundaries with a client who’s consuming more time than they should.

Often, those conversations become a much bigger issue in our minds than they are in reality. Try taking that first step and see what happens. You may be surprised at the results.

For example, for 11 years, one of my clients avoided directly asking her database for referrals.

She was exceptional at building relationships, consistently wowed her clients and delivered incredible service. But when it came time to simply ask for the referral, she just couldn’t bring herself to do it.

During one of our coaching sessions, she finally committed to trying. We roleplayed the dialogues to prepare.

The next time we met, she was practically beaming.

“Well… it only took me 11 years to finally ask for referrals. And who would’ve thought? They actually work! I got four new referrals last week just from asking!” she said.

Boom. Nothing else had changed. She simply had a conversation she’d been avoiding for over a decade.

If you’re feeling stuck, ask yourself, “What’s the conversation I’ve been avoiding?”

Then have it.

PRO TIP: When it comes to difficult conversations, I like to ask for permission first. Try something like, “Is it alright if I share the truth as I see it?” Asking for permission lowers defenses, builds trust, and prepares people to truly hear what you’re about to say.

3. The conversation that leads to confidence

People hire a real estate professional because they want someone who will help them navigate uncertainty, simplify difficult decisions, and confidently guide them through one of the biggest financial and emotional decisions of their lives.

That requires knowledge and confidence.

One of my favorite reminders is, “Their confidence in you is derived from your confidence in yourself.”

It means being willing to say, “Based on everything you’ve shared with me, here’s what I recommend.”

Or, “If you were my family, this is the advice I’d give you.”

Remember, they didn’t hire you to simply unlock doors or write contracts.

They hired you because they wanted a professional they could trust.

Why working by referral works

Working by referral continues to be the best way to build a thriving real estate business because it’s focused on relationships, not just transactions. And relationships are built one conversation at a time, creating trust, deepening relationships, and helping people move forward.

Have those conversations and watch how your business starts to change. Sign up for a free business consultation to get started on the process. You’ll get clear on your vision, discover what’s holding you back, see what’s working well for people just like you, and get action steps to move forward. Schedule your business consultation today.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related Posts

September 30, 2026

Buy back your hours: A simple road map for hiring your first virtual assistant


By Geraldine Kriegbaum, Buffini Member In this blog, Geraldine Kriegbaum shares her road map for hiring […]

September 24, 2026

Three questions real estate leaders are asking


By Ethan Beute, Buffini Chief Ambassador The problems sound different every time. Not enough hours in […]

September 24, 2026

How partnerships help your business grow


By Lana Rodriguez, Buffini Member In a previous blog, Lana Rodriguez shared her strategy for creating […]

August 27, 2026

The party is not the point


By Ken Taylor, REALTOR® at RE/MAX Signature Properties In this blog, Ken Taylor, a Buffini Member […]

August 27, 2026

Clear the clutter, create opportunity


By Melissa Winter Clutter has a way of sneaking into every part of our lives. Sometimes […]

August 12, 2026

How to Turn Summer Events into Referral Opportunities


Summer has a way of bringing people together. Neighborhood BBQs, baseball games, block parties, concerts in […]